Run 1: Cathy Ades Real Estate LLC, The Connolly Agency, Ward Wight Sotheby’s International Realty, Gavin Agency LLC
For an Allenhurst sale, I’d **interview these three first**—and choose the *specific listing agent*, not just the logo:
1. **Cathy Ades Real Estate LLC — my first call**
- Strongest evidence of very recent, high-end Allenhurst execution: it listed a home at **127 Cedar Avenue that sold for $4.85 million on June 22, 2026**, and its Allenhurst/West Allenhurst sold inventory includes several other local sales. It also currently carries Allenhurst listings. ([cathyades.com](https://www.cathyades.com/neighborhoods/153826709/allenhurst?utm_source=openai))
- Best fit if your property is a distinctive Allenhurst home, especially roughly **$1.5M–$5M+**, where hyperlocal pricing and buyer relationships matter.
- Ask to meet **Catherine Ades and/or Michael Ades** and to see their exact plan for your home.
2. **The Connolly Agency — strongest local-market-data alternative**
- Its agent **Joseph Baumann** is shown with **22 sales in Allenhurst/07711 in the prior 12 months** on Zillow’s agent directory. The firm also publishes Allenhurst-specific MLS-based reporting; it reported a **$4.85M median sold price** in the first half of 2026, albeit with longer marketing times. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/allenhurst-nj-07711/?utm_source=openai))
- Good choice if you want a polished local Shore brokerage with a data-heavy pricing conversation and a strong local buyer pipeline.
3. **Ward Wight Sotheby’s International Realty — best luxury-network comparison**
- Worth interviewing for an architecturally notable, renovated, waterfront/lake-adjacent, or **$3M+** home where out-of-area and second-home buyers may matter. Ward Wight has four residential sales offices and 82 licensed agents, and agents such as **Angela Pfisterer** and **Jacqueline Clark** serve Allenhurst. ([realtrends.com](https://www.realtrends.com/brokerage-profile/ward-wight-sotheby-s-international-realty-manasquan-nj/?utm_source=openai))
- Their advantage should be premium presentation and buyer reach—not a reason by itself to accept a weak list price or a long contract.
**Also interview if you prefer a small, truly local shop:**
- **Gavin Agency LLC**, headquartered at **560 Main Street in Allenhurst**. Agent **Timothy Siciliano** has long experience and a reported track record in the 07711 area. ([erealestatepro.com](https://erealestatepro.com/real_estate_agents/nj_others_real_estate_agents.shtml?utm_source=openai))
## My practical recommendation
- If your home is **over ~$2.5M or special/estate-like**: start with **Cathy Ades**, **The Connolly Agency**, and **Ward Wight Sotheby’s**.
- If it is a more standard **West Allenhurst home around $1M–$2M**: start with **Cathy Ades**, **The Connolly Agency**, and **Gavin Agency**.
Before signing, require each to give you:
- a written CMA using **closed sales**, not active listings;
- their own **last 5–10 Allenhurst/West Allenhurst listings** with list price, sale price, and days on market;
- a 30-day marketing plan with professional photography, video, broker outreach, and showing strategy;
- proposed list price, commission, contract length, and cancellation terms.
I would not hire a brokerage solely because it is national. In a tiny, high-value market such as Allenhurst, the agent’s recent nearby sales and pricing discipline are much more important.
Cited: cathyades.com, zillow.com, realtrends.com, erealestatepro.com
Run 2: Cathy Ades Real Estate LLC, The Connolly Agency, Gavin Agency LLC, Ward Wight Sotheby’s International Realty, Elana Properties LLC
For an Allenhurst sale, I’d interview **local boutique firms first**—this is a small, high-price, relationship-driven market, so the individual listing agent’s recent Allenhurst results matter more than a national logo.
### My shortlist
1. **Cathy Ades Real Estate LLC — my first call for most sellers**
- Cathy Ades has substantial current activity around Allenhurst/West Allenhurst and nearby shore towns. Her team reports 28 sales in the past 12 months, an average sale price around $1.4M, and a recent price range reaching about $5.6M. She currently has/had a $4.499M Allenhurst listing at 500 Corlies Avenue. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/profile/cathyades?utm_source=openai))
- **Best if:** your home is roughly **$1M–$5M**, or you want an energetic local listing team with plenty of current inventory and buyer contacts.
2. **The Connolly Agency — strongest local luxury alternative**
- The Connolly Agency is presently representing a roughly **$5.399M** Allenhurst property at 112 Euclid Avenue through Joseph Baumann, and Zillow’s Allenhurst agent data shows Baumann with recent local sales activity. ([elliman.com](https://www.elliman.com/sales/allenhurst-nj?utm_source=openai))
- **Best if:** your home is a higher-end historic, beach-area, or architecturally distinctive property where a more bespoke luxury presentation is warranted.
3. **Gavin Agency LLC — best “neighborhood brokerage” option**
- Gavin has an office right in Allenhurst, at **560 Main Street**, and agent Timothy Siciliano has meaningful Allenhurst-specific transaction history in the major listing portals’ data. ([njtgo.com](https://www.njtgo.com/towns/A/Allenhurst/Allenhurst%20Business%20and%20Shopping/Allenhurst_Business_and_Shopping.html?utm_source=openai))
- **Best if:** you value a very local firm, a broker with long local tenure, and direct access to a local network over a large marketing platform.
4. **Ward Wight Sotheby’s International Realty — best for a marquee luxury listing**
- Ward Wight Sotheby’s serves Allenhurst and the broader Jersey Shore luxury market; the firm’s Spring Lake-based leadership/agents cover Allenhurst and specialize in higher-end coastal, vacation, and investment properties. ([realtor.com](https://www.realtor.com/realestateagents/56bb34027e54f701002198c1?utm_source=openai))
- **Best if:** the house is **$3M+**, visually exceptional, or likely to appeal to second-home buyers from New York, North Jersey, or out of state. Ask which *specific* agent will run the listing and for Allenhurst/Deal/Long Branch comps—not merely the Sotheby’s brand.
5. **Elana Properties LLC — another credible Allenhurst boutique firm**
- Elana Properties is based in Allenhurst and currently shows a contract-signed Allenhurst listing at **315 Allen Avenue** for approximately **$3.45M**. ([njtgo.com](https://www.njtgo.com/towns/A/Allenhurst/Allenhurst%20Business%20and%20Shopping/Allenhurst_Business_and_Shopping.html?utm_source=openai))
- **Best if:** you prefer a small, local brokerage and want senior-level attention on a luxury or distinctive property.
### What I’d do in your position
- **If your house is under about $3M:** interview **Cathy Ades Real Estate, Gavin Agency, and The Connolly Agency**.
- **If it is about $3M–$6M+:** interview **Cathy Ades, The Connolly Agency, and Ward Wight Sotheby’s**—and add **Elana Properties** if you want a fourth local boutique comparison.
- **If I had to name one firm without knowing anything else about the house:** **Cathy Ades Real Estate LLC** is the most sensible first interview because of its current local activity, range, and visible Allenhurst inventory. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/profile/cathyades?utm_source=openai))
Before signing, require each brokerage to bring:
1. **Three truly comparable Allenhurst/West Allenhurst sold listings** from the last 6–12 months;
2. A written **pricing range and launch-price rationale**;
3. Their plan for professional pho
Cited: zillow.com, elliman.com, njtgo.com, realtor.com, homes.com