Run 1: Prime Mountain Properties, Kevin Charkosky, Jared Drager, Annie Maloney, Jane Terrell, CENTURY 21 MVP, Team Deborah Korlin, Ralph & Rasa Baldino, Tim & Irena McCoy, Tennessee Elite Realty, LLC, Charity Brown’s team, eXp Realty / The Avery Carl Team, Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty – Kings of Real Estate Team, Tracy King’s team, RE/MAX Adventure Realty
There isn’t one objective “best,” but based on recent local transaction/review rankings, these are the **specific Sevierville-area firms I’d put on a short list**:
1. **Prime Mountain Properties** — Especially strong local presence and several highly reviewed, high-volume agents. Notable names include **Kevin Charkosky**, **Jared Drager**, **Annie Maloney**, and **Jane Terrell**. Kevin Charkosky is ranked #1 by one MLS-data-based ranking service, while Zillow also shows several Prime Mountain agents with deep Sevierville sales histories and strong review counts. ([effectiveagents.com](https://www.effectiveagents.com/tn/sevierville?utm_source=openai))
2. **CENTURY 21 MVP** — A major Sevierville/Smokies brokerage with credible production across multiple teams. Consider **Team Deborah Korlin**, **Ralph & Rasa Baldino**, or **Tim & Irena McCoy**. Team Deborah Korlin is recognized by RealTrends as a verified top team by volume based on 2025 sales data. ([realtrends.com](https://www.realtrends.com/team-profile/team-deborah-korlin-tennessee-century-21-mvp/?utm_source=openai))
3. **Tennessee Elite Realty, LLC** — **Charity Brown’s team** is a particularly compelling choice for conventional residential buying or selling: FastExpert lists Brown as its top Sevierville agent, with 233 local sales over the prior three years, and Zillow lists the team with 144 sales in the last 12 months. ([fastexpert.com](https://www.fastexpert.com/top-real-estate-agents/sevierville-tn/?utm_source=openai))
4. **eXp Realty / The Avery Carl Team** — A leading option if your focus is a **Smoky Mountains cabin, vacation home, or short-term-rental investment**. Zillow reports 518 team sales in the prior 12 months and a price range reaching into multimillion-dollar property. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
5. **Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty – Kings of Real Estate Team** — **Tracy King’s team** has very high review volume and substantial Sevierville transaction experience. Zillow reports 200 team sales in the past 12 months, while FastExpert identifies 37 Sevierville buyer-side sales over three years. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
6. **RE/MAX Adventure Realty** — Worth interviewing, especially for a more established regional brokerage option; **Cheryl Hawkins** appeared near the top of a 2025 transaction/volume ranking for Sevierville. ([tabtablabs.com](https://tabtablabs.com/agents/top-real-estate-agents-sevierville-tn?utm_source=openai))
7. **Mountain Realty Group** — Another credible local brokerage to compare, with **Michael J. McConnell** appearing in the same top-producer ranking. ([tabtablabs.com](https://tabtablabs.com/agents/top-real-estate-agents-sevierville-tn?utm_source=openai))
**My practical shortlist:**
- **Selling a primary home:** Prime Mountain Properties, CENTURY 21 MVP, Tennessee Elite Realty.
- **Buying a cabin/STR investment:** Avery Carl Team at eXp, Prime Mountain Properties, CENTURY 21 MVP.
- **Want a highly process-driven large team:** Charity Brown/Tennessee Elite or Tracy King/Kings of Real Estate.
Before signing a buyer-representation or listing agreement, interview 2–3 **individual agents**, not just firms. Ask each for: (1) the last 10 comparable Sevierville sales, (2) their recent cabin/STR transactions if relevant, (3) expected response time, (4) exact commission/fee structure, and (5) whether they personally handle showings and negotiations.
Cited: effectiveagents.com, realtrends.com, fastexpert.com, zillow.com, tabtablabs.com
Run 2: Prime Mountain Properties, Tennessee Elite Realty, Century 21 MVP, eXp Realty / The Avery Carl Team, The Real Estate Firm, Local Realty Group, Mountain Realty Group, East Tennessee Realty
There isn’t one objectively “best” Sevierville brokerage—the right choice depends heavily on whether you’re buying a primary home, selling, purchasing a cabin, or underwriting a short-term-rental investment. But these are **specific firms with strong local presence and/or notable agent performance** worth interviewing:
1. **Prime Mountain Properties** — A particularly strong local option for Smoky Mountain cabins, vacation homes, and investment properties. Its agents show substantial Sevierville transaction histories and review volume, including Kevin Charkosky, Jared Drager, Annie Maloney, Jane Terrell, and the Mount LeConte Team. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
2. **Tennessee Elite Realty** — A high-volume local team/brokerage, especially worth considering for sellers and cabin/second-home buyers. Charity Brown’s team is listed with 144 team sales in the prior 12 months and 879 total Sevierville sales on Zillow. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
3. **Century 21 MVP** — A large regional brokerage with deep Sevier County coverage. Notable local teams include **Tim & Irena McCoy** and **Ralph & Rasa Baldino**; Zillow reports 26 and 36 team sales, respectively, in the preceding 12 months. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
4. **eXp Realty / The Avery Carl Team** — Especially relevant if you are buying or selling a vacation-rental cabin. Zillow shows Avery Carl’s team with **518 sales in the past 12 months**, and a broad price range reaching into luxury/investment territory. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
5. **The Real Estate Firm** — A Sevierville-based firm with a highly active local team led by **Kelly White**; Zillow lists 41 team sales over the previous 12 months and 360 total Sevierville sales. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
6. **Local Realty Group** — A local Sevierville brokerage with particular investor orientation, including short-term rentals, multifamily, BRRRR, and 1031-exchange work. ([biggerpockets.com](https://www.biggerpockets.com/tn/sevierville/agents?utm_source=openai))
7. **Mountain Realty Group** — A long-standing local brokerage worth adding to your comparison list, particularly for conventional residential, land, and local-market transactions. Its Sevierville office has a strong local review footprint. ([sevierville.ai](https://sevierville.ai/real-estate?utm_source=openai))
8. **East Tennessee Realty** — Consider interviewing them for traditional residential transactions; agent Fran Troxler has a substantial Sevierville sales history and strong Zillow reviews. ([zillow.com](https://www.zillow.com/professionals/real-estate-agent-reviews/sevierville-tn/?isSelling=true&utm_source=openai))
**If I were narrowing it down:**
- **Cabin / Airbnb / short-term-rental investment:** Prime Mountain Properties, Avery Carl Team at eXp, Tennessee Elite Realty, or Local Realty Group.
- **Selling a typical Sevierville home:** Tennessee Elite Realty, Century 21 MVP, Prime Mountain Properties, or The Real Estate Firm.
- **Land, acreage, or buildable lots:** Mountain Realty Group, Prime Mountain Properties, and a local Century 21 MVP agent are sensible firms to interview.
Before signing, interview **at least three named agents**, not just brokerages. Ask for: comparable sales they personally closed in your exact micro-market, their last 12-month Sevierville/Sevier County production, their proposed list-price rationale, and—for rentals—their underwriting assumptions for occupancy, management, insurance, HOA restrictions, and county/city permitting.
Cited: zillow.com, biggerpockets.com, sevierville.ai